‘Solid works
with plenty of variation. That goes for the lengths of the works too, I think
it was a good idea not to group them by size because the shorter pieces form
a nice break in between the longer stories.
Overall I think I'd say that 'Are "Friends" electric?' was my favourite, but other highlights include 'Featherweight' and 'One Street Corner Too Soon'. Also, 'Falling from Grace' is probably my favourite super short piece I've ever encountered.’
I gave it
three stars. And I’ve been thinking about that. It’s difficult to rate a
collection of stories on the same scale as fantastic novels and ongoing
series’. I feel like there should be a separate rating system. I mean, who could
honestly give a random collection five stars in comparison to their favourite
books? It seems illogical. I will say though, I was going to give it four,
thinking on a separate scale, but on reflection there were little problems I found
with most of the stories that prevented me from naming them as specific
recommendations. There’s no doubting his writing skill, it’s just the stories
themselves that irked me sometimes. Also, (cover your ears lads) size is an
issue. I don’t think it’s any coincidence my favourite works were the longer
pieces. There’s more time to build an affinity to characters, worlds and
situations. I’m keen to read longer pieces of his when the time comes, but
unfortunately a couple of months ago he declared his ongoing novel was going
to be put on hold!
I’ve also been
tucking into the ‘Mistborn’ series. I’m about two thirds of the way through
the first book and enjoying it thus far. The magic system is interesting. I
have to admit I was a bit hesitant when it was described to me beforehand by
friends. It’s described in a lot of detail. I guess the writer is just making
sure that the reader understands it fully at this early stage and will gradually
pull away from so much guide lining and hand holding the further I get into
the series. Much applause though, it’s good once you get to know it. Also the
way it’s introduced is something akin to perfect writing in terms of
technique/systems. There is a character that doesn’t know much about it at
the start and as she’s schooled by the more experienced characters we get to
learn alongside her, and wouldn’t you just know it? She gets to learn all the
variations whereas most people are only lucky enough to have one. A few
months back I was complaining that the unabridged version of ‘Moby Dick’ was
putting me off because the explanations of equivalent things such as
equipment were instead reflective and detached. Well here’s a better way of
doing it. Also, it’s that much easier without such a restrictive word limit.
Not much
sporting input this month other than a tip of the hat towards Novak Djokovic
for winning the Tour Finals and a bit of nail biting as Arsenal went into the
international break with a reduced lead at the top after an unfortunate result
at Old Trafford. Until next time, buh-bye!
|
Follow me on Twitter - www.twitter.com/PaulJIsaac
"Like" my page on Facebook - http://on.fb.me/HKJOXk
Follow me on Tumblr. – http://paul106i.tumblr.com/
1 comment:
Hi Paul,
I stumbled across your review on Goodreads (I don't know why I didn't get any kind of notification from the site itself), and just wanted to thank you for taking the time to review the book. I'm glad you enjoyed at least some of the stories!
Incidentally, I have very similar reservations to you with regard to rating short story collections - a single rating doesn't make a whole lot of sense in many ways. Particularly with a collection like mine that has no unifying theme or style. It's much easier to rate a novel.
Post a Comment